Within-shift variability of short-term exposure to organic solvent in indoor workplaces

This study examined the degree of within-shift variability of short-term exposure concentrations for workers exposed to organic solvents in indoor workplaces. For this purpose, 117 exposure data sets of 15-minute time-weighted average (15-min TWA) and those of 60-min TWA were collected from 53 workers employed in the offset printing, gravure printing, screen printing, machine control board production, fiber-reinforced plastic production, hard metal production, electrical parts production, and chemical synthesizing industries. Data analysis showed that the tenth, fiftieth, and ninetieth percentiles of the geometric standard deviations of 15-min TWA values [GSD(15m)] were 1.4, 2.3, and 4.5, respectively; and those of GSD(60m) were 1.2, 1.7, and 3.4, respectively. Based on an assumption of lognormal exposure distribution, the maximum values of 15-min TWA (the 98.4th percentile) were estimated to be 4.3, 36, and 650 times as high as the minimum one (the 1.6th percentile) for the low, middle, and high exposure variabilities, respectively; and to be 2.0, 4.3, and 8.2 times the 8-hour TWA value, respectively. Consequently, when the 8-hour TWA exceeds 0.23 times (1/4.3) the short-term exposure limit value, the high short-term exposure condition should be evaluated. The maximum values of 60-min TWA (the 93.8th percentile) were estimated to be 1.8, 5.1 and 43 times as high as the minimum one, respectively; and to be 1.3, 2.0, and 3.1 times the 8-hour TWA value, respectively. The relationship between production factors and within-shift exposure variability was also examined. The intermittent solvent use group had significantly higher median values of GSD(15m) and GSD(60m) than the continuous group. The mobile pollutant source group had a significantly higher median value of GSD(60m) than the stationary group.