The apparently symmetrical hexagonal bilayer hemoglobin from Lumbricus terrestris has a large dipole moment

The giant approximately 3.6 MDa hexagonal bilayer hemoglobin (HBL Hb) from Lumbricus terrestris consists of 12 213-kDa dodecamers of four globin chains ([b + a + c]3[d]3) tethered to a central scaffold of approximately 36 non-globin, linker subunits L1-L4 (24-32 kDa). Three-dimensional reconstructions obtained by electron cryomicroscopy showed it to have a D6 point-group symmetry, with the two layers rotated approximately 16 degrees relative to each other. Measurement of the dielectric constants of the Hb and the dodecamer over the frequency range 5-100 kHz indicated relaxation frequencies occurring at 20-40 and 300 kHz, respectively, substantially lower than the 700-800 kHz in HbA. The dipole moments calculated using Oncley's equation were 17,300 +/- 2300 D and 1400 D for the Hb and dodecamer, respectively. The approximately threefold higher dipole moment of the dodecamer relative to HbA is consistent with an asymmetric shape in solution suggested by small-angle X-ray scattering. Although a two-term Debye equation and a prolate ellipsoid of revolution model provided a good fit to the experimental dielectric dispersion of the dodecamer, a three-term Debye equation based on an oblate ellipsoid of revolution model was required to fit the asymmetric dielectric dispersion curve of the Hb: the required additional term may represent either an induced dipole moment or a substructure which rotates independently of the main permanent dipole component of the Hb. The D6 point-group symmetry implies that the dipole moments of the dodecamers cancel out. Thus, in addition to a possible contribution from fluctuations of the proton distribution, the large dipole moment of the Hb may be due to an asymmetric distribution of the heterogeneous linker subunits.