Conformation of kainic acid in solution from molecular modelling and NMR spectra

Conformational behaviour of kainic acid in aqueous solution was elucidated by molecular mechanics and dynamics. The pucker of the five-membered ring in kainic acid was examined and compared with that of model compounds. In cyclopentane there is no barrier to pseudorotation, so that all puckered states coexist. In pyrrolidinium, the presence of a hetero-atom in the ring introduces a small barrier (about 0.6 kcal mol(-1)) to pseudorotation, separating two stable regions, A and B, which are equivalent by symmetry. In proline, the presence of the carboxylate group on C2 removes the symmetry but two stable conformational minima, A and B, remain. In kainic acid, the presence of side-chains on C3 and C4 introduces complications resulting in additional sub-minima in both regions, A and B. In solution, kainic acid is a complex mixture of conformers with comparable energies, because of the combination of several stable states of the pyrrolidinium ring with the torsional degrees of freedom arising from the two side-chains. The individual geometries, energies, and estimates of relative populations of these conformers were obtained from molecular dynamics simulations. The calculations were validated by a comparison of predicted inter-proton distances and vicinal proton coupling constants with the experimental quantities derived from NMR spectra.