Squamous cell carcinoma of temporal bone: reported on 33 patients

This study assessed the treatment results of a series of 33 patients with squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) of the temporal bone and evaluated the efficacy of mastoidectomy combined with perioperative radiation therapy protocol.

Thirty-three patients with biopsy-proven SCC invaded to the temporal bone were reviewed retrospectively and staged into three subgroups according to the University of Pittsburgh TNM Staging System. There were 3 patients with Stage I and II disease(tumor confined to auditory canal), 17 patients with Stage III (tumor involving the middle ear or mastoid), and 13 patients with Stage IV(more extensive disease). Two patients were treated by surgery alone. Eleven patients received irradiation only, and the remaining 20 patients underwent combined surgery and perioperative radiotherapy. The surgical intervention included sleeve resection for patients with Stage I and II lesions and mastoidectomy for all patients with Stage III and IV lesions except 1 who had subtotal temporal bone resection. The radiation dose delivered was in the range of 3500 approximately 10 000 cGy, with an average dose of 6560 cGy.

The five-year survival rate for the whole series was 51.7% by the life-table analysis. After being staged into three subgroups (ie, Stage I + II, Stage III, and Stage IV), the estimated five-year survival rates were 100%, 68. 8%, and 19.6%, respectively (p = 0.04). Radiation alone yielded a 28. 7% five-year survival, while combined surgery and irradiation gave a result of 59.6% (p = 0.80). For patients treated with planned combined therapy, the actuarial five-year survival rates were 72.7% (8/11) for Stage III disease and 12.5% (1/8) for Stage IV disease (p = 0.02). Twelve patients who died of disease did so of local recurrence (10 cases), cervical metastases (1 case), and liver metastases (1 case), with 70% of succumbing to their diseases within two years. Complications include osteonecrosis (n = 1), osteitis (n = 3), radiation dermatitis (n = 2), facial nerve palsy (n = 2), and delayed healing (n = 2). Data on clinical presentation and treatment modality were also analyzed.

The results of mastoidectomy with removal of all gross tumor, combined with planned perioperative irradiation therapy, seems to be a useful approach for SCC of the temporal bone. This gives at least as good, and possibly better, five-year survival than temporal bone resection. The mastoidectomy procedure creates less operative morbidity and mortality. To facilitate the development of more effective means of treating advanced disease, an accepted staging system and cooperative group investigation is necessary.