The effect of using different culling regimens on genetic response with two-trait, two-stage selection in a nucleus...

Stochastic simulation was used to study the effect on genetic response and inbreeding of various two-stage two-trait culling strategies. Four different parameter sets were considered for the two traits, BW and egg number. Selection of replacement animals was based on animal model best linear unbiased prediction (BLUP) to obtain estimated breeding values (EBV) at the second stage. Culling at Stage 1 was based on either animal model BLUP or phenotypes, and information from culled animals was either available or not available for calculation of second stage EBV. Besides founder individuals, six discrete generations were considered. Culling based on BLUP of two traits at Stage 1 produced higher response than culling on phenotypic evaluations. It was found that culling based on phenotypic evaluation and not carrying information to the second stage reduce rates of response by 9 to 17% and produced inbreeding higher than or close to that of BLUP selection. This study clearly shows that a double penalty of less response and higher inbreeding is generally paid for not using all information. Optimum selection schemes will depend on relative costs and benefits of collecting and processing the extra information required for full BLUP selection schemes.