Rational combinatorial library design. 3. Simulated annealing guided evaluation (SAGE) of molecular diversity: a...

We have developed a novel method for molecular diversity sampling called SAGE (simulated annealing guided evaluation of molecular diversity). Compounds in chemical databases or virtual combinatorial libraries are conventionally represented as points in multidimensional descriptor space. The SAGE algorithm selects a desired number of optimally diverse points (compounds) from a database. The diversity of a subset of points is measured by a specially designed diversity function, and the most diverse subset is selected using Simulated Annealing (SA) as the optimization tool. Application of SAGE to two simulated data sets of randomly distributed points in two-dimensional space afforded diverse and representative selection as judged by visual inspection. SAGE was also applied, in comparison with random sampling, to two other simulated data sets with points distributed among many clusters. We found that SAGE sampling covered significantly more clusters than the random sampling. By defining a fraction of data points as active, we also compared SAGE with random sampling in terms of hit rates. We showed that when the percentage of active points was low, the hit rates obtained by SAGE were always higher than those obtained by random sampling. When the percentage of active points was high, the performance of SAGE, in terms of individual hit rates, depended upon the data structure. However, in all cases, SAGE performed better than random sampling when cluster hit rates were used as the criterion.