Raman microspectrometry studies of brushite cement: in vivo evolution in a sheep model

Calcium phosphate hydraulic cements are promising synthetic bone grafting materials. Brushite-based cements were implanted for 6 and 12 months in the distal condyle of sheep femur, and their in vivo evolution was investigated by Raman microspectrometry. This new technique can probe small volumes in the cubic micrometer range. Its resolution allows a very fine analysis of crystalline changes in calcium phosphate mixtures at the microscopic level. First, Raman spectra of pure brushite, monetite, and beta-tricalcium phosphate (beta-TCP) were recorded, in order to set a data base for the basic components of brushite cements. These spectra show significant differences in the vibration mode v1 for the phosphate ion (988 and 878 cm(-1) for brushite, 988 and 900 cm(-1) for monetite, 968 and 948 cm(-1) for beta-TCP). These differences are strong enough as to allow the qualitative and quantitative analysis of these crystalline phases in the cement. Implanted sheep femur samples were harvested after 24 and 52 weeks post-op, and prepared for Raman analysis in the form of 1-mm-thick sections. Implants at 24 weeks show a core of residual cement isolated from the surrounding bone by fibroconnective tissue. No trace of brushite was detected by micro-Raman analysis in this area, but instead, a mixture of beta-TCP and Type-B carbonated apatite, the latter being very close in composition and structure to the mineral fraction of normal bone in the vicinity of the implant. Implants recovered after 52 weeks show a decrease of the bone/residual cement perimeter, whereas new trabeculations are formed in the implanted zone; the small amounts of residual cement still present are substantially transformed into Type-B carbonated apatite containing small amounts of proteins. In the same area, some beta-TCP particles are also detected showing that, contrary to brushite, the excess beta-TCP originally present in the cement is not completely metabolized. In the implanted zone already converted into trabecular bone, Raman microspectrometry shows the characteristic spectrum of normal bone.