The expert witness: defending the profession or prosecuting your peers

The use of CRNAs as expert witnesses in court cases is well-established. The CRNA who acts as a legal consultant or an expert witness is not retained merely to pontificate in the courtroom based on their considerable experience and expertise. The CRNA will undertake many roles in the process of assisting the attorney including those of (1) record reviewer and data analyst, (2) researcher and retriever, (3) synthesizer, and (4) teacher. Beyond these roles is the philosophical premise that the person best suited to evaluate the competence of a nurse anesthetist is another nurse anesthetist. Poor practitioners who are a danger to the public ought to be held accountable for their failings, whereas excellent practitioners who are mistakenly accused of negligence ought to be defended. Although challenging and time consuming, the role of the legal consultant and expert witness is rewarding in both financial and personal satisfaction terms. The role and functions of the CRNA who takes on the challenges of appearing as an expert witness or legal consultant is explored. The fine points of medical malpractice is not discussed, except as a cursory overview. The goal is to provide the practicing CRNA with the basic tools needed for these roles.