Shear bond strength of techniques for bonding esthetic veneers to metal

New composites with improved qualities have been introduced to the dental profession as alternatives to porcelain. There is concern about the strength and reliability of new metal-resin bonding systems when these composites are used as esthetic veneers over metal frameworks.

This in vitro study compared the shear bond strength of 2 metal-resin bonding techniques with the bond strength of conventional porcelain fused-to-metal (PFM). Effects of water storage and thermocycling were also evaluated.

Ninety disks, cast in a medium gold, high noble PFM alloy, were divided equally into 6 groups, and received 3 treatments for veneering: conventional feldspathic porcelain on 1 group, and a composite (Artglass) bonded to the metal, using 2 metal-resin bonding techniques. Specimens were tested in shear, half of them after a 24-hour dry storage at room temperature and the rest after 10-day storage in normal saline solution at 37 degrees C and thermocycling. Fractured specimens were evaluated under x10 magnification to determine the nature of failure. Statistical analysis was performed with 2-factor analysis of variance (ANOVA).

Mean shear bond strength values before and after wet storage and thermocycling were 29.66 and 22.91 MPa for the PFM group; 21.43 and 17.92 MPa for the Siloc group; and 19.34 and 15.64 for the etched group, respectively. The PFM group exhibited significantly higher bond strength values compared with the other 2 groups (P<.001). All groups showed a significant decrease in bond strength values after wet storage and thermocycling (P<.001).

Wet storage and thermocycling caused a significant decrease in shear bond strength of all specimens. Shear bond strength of conventional feldspathic PFM was significantly higher than that of the 2 metal-resin bonding techniques tested. The 2 latter techniques did not reveal any statistically significant differences.