Could we treat more unruptured ectopic pregnancies with intramuscular methotrexate?

The main reason for the restricted use of methotrexate in the treatment of ectopic pregnancy (EP) obviously is the fear of tubal rupture in patients with lower abdominal pain after the administration of methotrexate. Therefore, we wanted to find out if patient characteristics at first presentation, such as age, pretreatment beta-hCG level, adnexal mass as visualized by transvaginal ultrasonography, or history of prior EP, would identify patients at risk for tubal rupture if they were hemodynamically stable and showed no signs of peritoneal irritation. We examined whether more patients could have been treated medically with methotrexate, because tubal rupture was unforeseeable at first presentation and inclusion criteria for methotrexate treatment were fulfilled. From January 1996 to August 1998, 122 patients diagnosed as having EP were treated at the Gynecologic Department of the University Hospital of Vienna. Inclusion criteria for medical treatment with intramuscular methotrexate (50 mg/ m(2) body surface area) were (1) hemodynamic stability, (2) an unruptured ectopic mass < or = 5 cm at the greatest dimension demonstrated at transvaginal ultrasonography; (3) beta-hCG level < or = 5,000 mIU/ml; (4) no cardiac activity of the extrauterine embryo; (5) wish of future fertility, and (6) informed consent. Patients with hemodynamic instability, severe abdominal pain, an ectopic mass > or = 5 cm at the greatest dimension, beta-hCG levels > or = 5,000 mIU/ml, cardiac activity of the extrauterine embryo, and no wish of future fertility, or disagreement with methotrexate treatment, primarily underwent surgery. Despite the fact that none of the above patient characteristics at first presentation identified patients at risk for tubal rupture, only 60/122 patients (49%) actually underwent medical treatment whereas our inclusion criteria would have granted medical treatment in 101/122 patients (83%). We determined the actual and maximal possible percentages of patients with unruptured EP eligible for medical treatment of EP with intramuscular single-dose methotrexate 50 mg/m(2) body surface area. Our data show that tubal rupture in hemodynamically stable patients is not foreseeable and should not lead to a restricted use of medical treatment in patients preferring methotrexate.