Measurement of relative antioxidant activity of compounds: a methodological note

The relative activities of some hydrogen-donating antioxidants were assessed by comparing their activities with that of Trolox (Trolox equivalent antioxidant capacity, TEAC) for scavenging the ABTS radical cation (ABTS.+) generated in the aqueous phase. We have verified, however, that TEAC values may change with the concentration of compounds and with the measuring times used. Not withstanding, TEAC values do not differ significantly if the compounds have kinetic curves of ABTS.+ formation similar to that of Trolox. This is the case with ascorbic acid, whose TEAC values, determined by using five concentrations at three different measuring times, are very close. For the flavonoids studied (catechin, rutin, naringenin and silibinin) which have kinetic curves of ABTS.+ formation different from that of Trolox, the TEAC values decrease with increasing concentrations of the compounds for each measuring time, and increase with increasing measuring times for each concentration. In the present study, we conclude that, in order to evaluate relative antioxidant activities of compounds by the ABTS assay, it is essential to perform kinetic studies to assess scavenging of ABTS.+ by these compounds. Therefore, when the TEAC values of compounds are determined for more than one measuring time, we may be sure that all the antioxidant potential of compounds is being considered and whether or not it is possible to establish a hierarchy for their antioxidant activities.