Field evaluation of a portable photoionization detector for assessing exposure to solvent mixtures

To evaluate a portable photoionization detector for assessing personal exposure to solvent mixtures, a set of 26 side-by-side, time-weighted average (TWA) personal breathing zone samples were collected during various construction painting tasks by two different sampling methods: (1) standard charcoal sorbent tubes analyzed by gas chromatography (CST/GC), and (2) a direct-reading photoionization detector coupled with an extended data-logger (PID). The TWA concentrations of the hydrocarbons detected by CST/GC analysis were summed for comparison with the TWA concentration obtained from the direct-reading PID. Based on linear regression between the log TWA concentrations of the two sampling methods, the data were highly correlated (r2 = 0.95). Since the solvents had effects that may be considered additive, threshold limit values (TLVs) for mixtures were developed using American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists formulas to evaluate solvent exposure. The logs of the TLV mixture data from the sampling methods were highly correlated (r2 = 0.94). Based on the linear regression analyses, the response of the portable PID was highly correlated to the CST/GC results for hydrocarbon mixtures encountered during various painting tasks. Due to the short duration of tasks, highly fluctuating exposures, and complexity of the mixtures, the PID may provide the most cost-effective, detailed exposure assessment for solvent mixtures.