Mechanical and histologic evaluation of Collagraft in an ovine lumbar fusion model

The purpose of this study was to determine the effectiveness of a composite material composed of Type I bovine dermal collagen, 65% hydroxyapatite, and 35% tricalcium phosphate ceramic (Collagraft Bone Graft Matrix Strip NeuColl Incorporated, Palo Alto, CA) as a bone graft substitute for spinal fusion with and without the use of autologous bone marrow in an ovine lumbar spine model with pedicle screw fixation. Twenty-four adult sheep underwent a single level posterolateral (intertransverse process) L3-L4 lumbar fusion with one of three graft materials combined with rigid pedicle screw fixation. The three graft materials were Collagraft, Collagraft with marrow, and autogenous corticocancellous bone graft. Animals were euthanized 6 months after surgery and evaluated using dual energy x-ray absorptiometry, radiographs, histologic analysis, and mechanical testing. Dual energy xray absorptiometry between the transverse processes revealed that the mineral densities for the two Collagraft groups were significantly higher than the autogenous bone graft group. Histologic analysis confirmed that Collagraft was highly compatible and was well incorporated into the fusion mass. Both Collagraft groups had thick trabeculae and a mixture of lamellar and plexiform bone. The autogenous bone graft group had a smaller fusion complex, composed primarily of lamellar bone with thinner and fewer trabeculae. All three groups had similar mechanical properties. These results support the use of Collagraft in spinal fusion with pedicle screw fixation.