Translaryngeal tracheostomy: two modified techniques versus the basic technique--early experience in 75 critically ill adults

Elective tracheostomy is an established procedure in the management of ICU patients on long-term ventilation. In addition, percutaneous tracheostomy techniques are increasingly being used. In 1997, Fantoni's translaryngeal technique (TLT), another minimally invasive procedure, was introduced. While clinical studies of TLT showed that the technique is safe and can be performed rapidly, technical difficulties which sometimes led to prolonged operating times were also noted. Our study compared the basic TLT technique to a modified TLT approach and to TLT performed with the manufacturer's new, improved "Straight Cannula" set. Twenty-five patients were enrolled in each group, and the advantages and disadvantages of the respective techniques were evaluated.

Surgical ICU of a university hospital.

Seventy-five adult, surgical intensive care patients.

Average operating times with the modified TLT techniques were significantly shorter, 4 and 5 min respectively, as compared to 11 min for the basic TLT technique. Initially, use of the new, improved TLT set resulted in a complete passage of the tracheal cannula in two patients; uneventful Griggs's tracheostomy was performed instead. Regardless of the technique used, no other perioperative complications were noted and the perioperative gas exchange remained unaffected by the tracheostomy procedure.

The modified TLT procedures are safer and more readily performed than the basic technique. Difficulty in the retrograde passage of the guide wire was seen only occasionally with the modified techniques. Based on our data we conclude that the modified techniques are superior to the basic technique and represent significant progress in TLT.