Current management of calculi in horseshoe kidneys

To assess treatment options for calculi in horseshoe kidneys and the impact of extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy (ESWL) on the management of renal stones.

From June 1971 to January 1998, 52 patients with horseshoe kidneys and calculi received treatment at our Urologic Stone Unit. There were 40 men (77%) and 12 women (23%). Average patient age was 41 years (range: 10-70 years). Clinical onset, treatment received and outcome were evaluated retrospectively. A successful outcome was defined as a patient without residual calculi or with fragments <0.4 cm in size.

Clinical onset was mainly low back pain in 37 patients (71%). Eighty-nine stones were treated, i.e. an average of 1.7 treatments per patient. Before the ESWL era (May 1987), we performed two heminephrectomies, 16 pyelolithotomies, 12 pyelolithotomies combined with ureteropyeloplasty and one percutaneous nephrolithotomy. Since the advent of ESWL, seven pyelolithotomies and three pyelolithotomies combined with ureteropyloplasty have been done. ESWL was used to treat 48 calculi. In three cases the patient was placed in the prone position due to difficulties in stone focusing. In 37 cases (77%) patients were either rendered stone-free or had residual fragments <0.4 cm in size. Urinary diversion for obstruction was carried out in two cases (4%).

At present ESWL is the first-choice treatment for calculi in horseshoe kidneys. It involves no significant focusing difficulties and is associated with a low incidence of obstructive complications. Open surgery is indicated in cases of stone-related pyeloureteral stenosis and in the presence of calculi >2-2.5 cm in size.