Analysis of the turin umbilical cord blood bank registry

The polymorphic nature of the HLA system reduces a patient's probability of finding an HLA-compatible unrelated bone marrow (BM) donor, even though more than 6 million individuals are enrolled in international registries. Recently, umbilical cord blood (UCB) has been successfully employed as a source of HPCs. The use of such cells reduces the risk of GVHD and allows transplants with one or two HLA mismatches. UCB represents an expensive resource: therefore, it is necessary to carefully manage the UCB unit inventory.

The current study analyzed the genetic heterogeneity of HLA-A, -B, and -DR gene frequencies between pools of UCB and unrelated-donor BM in the Piedmont (an administrative region of Italy). An Italian hematology patient's probability of finding complete or partial matches as a function of donor pool size was determined by considering subsamples randomly selected from the local unrelated BM donors.

The HLA gene frequencies in UCB and unrelated-donor BM pools were not significantly different. The search simulation, based on actual HLA phenotypes, showed that the percentage of Italian patients matched with an HPC unit increases remarkably if 1 or 2 mismatches are accepted, reaching a proportion of 90 percent with an inventory of only about 500 units, while the increment is not so remarkable if the number of UCB units is greater.

To optimize economic resources and to be internationally competitive, UCB banks should aim to increase the genetic heterogeneity of their units rather than increasing the UCB inventory, acquire efficient quality control systems, and acquire and preserve UCB units with a greater number of nucleated cells.