Related Experiment Video
Updated: Aug 8, 2026
06:26
Pulling Membrane Nanotubes from Giant Unilamellar Vesicles
Published on: December 7, 2017
Limits to optimization: fluid dynamics, adhesive strength and the evolution of shape in limpet shells
1Stanford University, Hopkins Marine Station, Pacific Grove, CA 93950, USA. mwdenny@leland.stanford.edu
The Journal of Experimental Biology
|August 10, 2000
Summary
Limpets
Area of Science:
- Marine Biology
- Evolutionary Biology
- Biomechanics
Background:
- Limpets inhabit wave-swept rocky shores with high water velocities.
- Extreme hydrodynamic forces (lift and drag) challenge limpet adhesion.
- Conical shell shape is thought to reduce forces and aid adhesion.
Purpose of the Study:
- Investigate how limpet shell shape influences lift and drag forces.
- Explore hydrodynamic forces as a selective factor in limpet shell evolution.
- Compare optimal hydrodynamic shapes with actual limpet shell morphology.
Main Methods:
- Tested various limpet-like models to measure lift and drag.
- Analyzed force variations based on shell height-to-radius ratios.
- Examined the position of the shell apex in relation to hydrodynamic forces.
Main Results:
- Lift dominates at low height-to-radius ratios; drag dominates at high ratios.
- Optimal shape for minimizing dislodgment risk has a height-to-radius ratio of 1.06 with a centered apex.
- Real limpets exhibit a mean height-to-radius ratio of 0.68 with an anteriorly placed apex.
Conclusions:
- Hydrodynamically optimal shell shapes are not typical in real limpets.
- Strong adhesive systems in limpets likely mitigate hydrodynamic dislodgement.
- Tenacious adhesion may have overridden selection for hydrodynamically optimized shells, allowing other factors to influence shell shape.
Related Concept Videos
01:23Membrane Fluidity
Cell membranes are composed of phospholipids, proteins, and carbohydrates loosely attached to one another through chemical interactions. Molecules are generally able to move about in the plane of the membrane, giving the membrane its flexible nature called fluidity. Two other features of the membrane contribute to membrane fluidity: the chemical structure of the phospholipids and the presence of cholesterol in the membrane.Fatty acids tails of phospholipids can be either saturated or...
02:57Surface Tension, Capillary Action, and Viscosity
Surface Tension
The various IMFs between identical molecules of a substance are examples of cohesive forces. The molecules within a liquid are surrounded by other molecules and are attracted equally in all directions by the cohesive forces within the liquid. However, the molecules on the surface of a liquid are attracted only by about one-half as many molecules. Because of the unbalanced molecular attractions on the surface molecules, liquids contract to form a shape that minimizes the number...
The various IMFs between identical molecules of a substance are examples of cohesive forces. The molecules within a liquid are surrounded by other molecules and are attracted equally in all directions by the cohesive forces within the liquid. However, the molecules on the surface of a liquid are attracted only by about one-half as many molecules. Because of the unbalanced molecular attractions on the surface molecules, liquids contract to form a shape that minimizes the number...
01:20Characteristics of Fluids
When a force is applied parallel to the top surface of a solid, it resists the applied force due to the internal frictional forces between the layers of the solid known as shearing resistance. However, when the force is removed, the shearing forces restore the original shape of the solid. Other deformation forces also cause temporary changes in shape if the forces are not beyond a threshold magnitude. Solids tend to retain their shape, making the study of their rest and motion easier. Beyond...
01:20Stokes' Law
Viscous forces, like friction, are intermolecular forces that resist the relative motion of molecules over each other. When a solid body moves through a liquid, viscous forces drag it in the opposite direction. The force's magnitude depends on the solid's shape and size, as well as its speed and the liquid's coefficient of viscosity, density and temperature.
The expression for the force on a solid spherical object in a fluid is called Stokes' law. Stokes' law is valid only for low Reynolds...
The expression for the force on a solid spherical object in a fluid is called Stokes' law. Stokes' law is valid only for low Reynolds...
01:22Surface Tension of Fluid
Surface tension is a fundamental property of fluids, occurring at the boundary between a liquid and a gas or between two immiscible liquids. This phenomenon arises from the cohesive forces between molecules at the fluid's surface, creating an effect similar to a stretched elastic membrane. Inside each fluid, molecules are equally attracted in all directions by neighboring molecules, but surface molecules experience a net inward force, resulting in surface tension.
Surface tension varies with...
Surface tension varies with...
01:17Steady, Laminar Flow Between Parallel Plates
Understanding steady, laminar flow between parallel plates is essential for analyzing and designing flow in narrow rectangular channels, commonly found in various water conveyance and drainage systems. The Navier-Stokes equations govern fluid motion and are generally challenging to solve due to their nonlinearity. However, simplifications are possible in certain cases, like the steady laminar flow between parallel plates. For this scenario, we assume steady, incompressible, laminar flow.