Critical relationship between TCR signaling potential and TCR affinity during thymocyte selection

Whether a developing thymocyte becomes positively or negatively selected is thought to be determined by the affinity/avidity of its TCR for MHC/peptide ligands expressed in the thymus. Presumably, differences in affinity translate into differences in the potency of the ensuing TCR-mediated signals, and these differences in signal strength determine the outcome of thymocyte selection. However, there is little direct evidence establishing a relationship between TCR-ligand affinity and signal strength during positive and negative selection. The TCR complex contains multiple signaling motifs, known as immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motifs (ITAMs) that are required for T cell activation. To examine the effects of TCR signal strength on selection, the signaling potential of the TCR was modified by substituting transgenic TCR zeta-chains containing either three, one, or zero ITAMs for endogenous (3-ITAM) zeta-chain. These zeta-chain variants were then bred into different alphabetaTCR transgenic backgrounds. We report that reductions in TCR signaling potential have distinct effects on the selection of thymocytes expressing different TCRs, and that the requirement for zeta-chain ITAMs critically depends upon the specificity and apparently, affinity, of the TCR for its selecting ligand(s).