Approach to communication, speech perception and intelligibility after paediatric cochlear implantation

The aim of this study was to explore the relationship between approach to communication, speech perception and speech intelligibility after cochlear implantation of young children with profound early deafness. A prospective speech perception and speech intelligibility assessment was undertaken on a consecutive group of implanted children. There were 46 children at the three-year, 26 at the four-year and 20 at the five-year intervals. All had been born deaf or deafened before the age of three and received cochlear implants before the age of seven. Their speech perception ability and the intelligibility of their speech were measured before cochlear implantation and annually thereafter. The children's communication had been classified by their teachers of the deaf at each interval into one of two categories: those using an oral approach and those using a signing approach. Results revealed that at all intervals, those children classified as using oral communication significantly exceeded those using signed communication on measures of speech perception and intelligibility (p<0.05). When those children who had changed from signed to oral communication were compared at the three-year interval with those who used oral communication throughout, there was no significant difference in their results. However, it remains to be explored whether children use oral communication after cochlear implantation because they are doing well, or whether they do well because they are using oral communication.