Radiosurgery for epilepsy associated with cavernous malformation: retrospective study in 49 patients

Microsurgical resection of a cavernous malformation (CM) with or without associated cortical resection can provide efficient treatment of drug-resistant associated epilepsy. To explore the potential alternative role of radiosurgery and to evaluate its safety and efficacy for this indication, we conducted a retrospective multicenter study.

We retrospectively reviewed the files of patients with long-lasting drug-resistant epilepsy, presumably caused by CM, who were treated by gamma knife (GK) surgery for the control of their epilepsy in five centers (Marseilles, Komaki City, Prague, Graz, and Sheffield). A satisfactory follow-up was available for 49 patients (mean follow-up period, 23.66 +/- 13 mo). The mean duration of epilepsy before the GK procedure was 7.5 (+/-9.3) years. The mean frequency of seizures was 6.9/month (+/-14). The mean marginal radiation dose was 19.17 Gy +/- 4.4 (range, 11.25-36). Among the 49 patients, 17 (35%) had a CM located in or involving a highly functional area.

At the last follow-up examination, 26 patients (53%) were seizure-free (Engel's Class I), including 24 in Class IA (49%) and 2 patients with occasional auras (Class IB, 4%). A highly significant decrease in the number of seizures was achieved in 10 patients (Class IIB, 20%). The remaining 13 patients (26%) showed little or no improvement. The mediotemporal site was associated with a higher risk of failure. One patient bled during the observation period, and another experienced radiation-induced edema with transient aphasia. Postradiosurgery excision was performed in five patients, and a second radiosurgical treatment was carried out in one patient.

This series is the first to specifically evaluate the capability of GK surgery to safely and efficiently treat epilepsy associated with CM. Seizure control can be reached when a good electroclinical correlation exists between CM location and epileptogenic zone. Although we do not recommend GK surgery for prevention of bleeding for a CM that has not bled previously, our findings suggest that GK surgery can be proposed for the treatment of epilepsy when the CM is located in a highly functional area.