Failure to detect Bartonella henselae infection in synovial fluid from sufferers of chronic arthritis

Bartonella henselae causes granulomatous and indolent infection in the immune competent human, and angioproliferation in the context of persistent infection and impaired immunity. This bacterium is found in up to 40% of household cats, from which humans acquire it by either a cat scratch or a bite (hence the name, cat-scratch disease). Approximately 5% of Australian and US blood donors have serological evidence of past infection, but most associated illnesses are mild or subclinical. A number of lines of evidence prompted us to consider a relationship between rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and Bartonella infection. These include epidemiological associations with household pet exposure; apparent responsiveness of some RA cases to tetracycline therapy; the granulomatous and angioproliferative nature of Bartonella lesions; the insidiousness and high seroprevalence of this infection in the community; and even reported Bartonella infection mimicking juvenile RA. In a small group of patients with chronic arthritides, we found no direct evidence of humoral antibodies to, nor of persistent infection with, Bartonella henselae in synovial fluid. While larger and more invasive studies are likely to provide more confident exclusions of this hypothesis, this suggests that persistent Bartonella infection is unlikely to play a major role in RA.