Efficacy of adjunctive cricopharyngeus myotomy in supraglottic laryngectomy

This study investigates prospectively the effect of concurrent cricopharyngeus myotomy (CPM) on swallowing following horizontal supraglottic laryngectomy (SL) using fiberoptic, radiographic, and manometric evaluations and suggests possible mechanisms regarding the role of CPM following SL. Six patients undergoing horizontal SL between 1995 and 1997 were enrolled in a prospective evaluation with a followup of 0.5-2.25 years. Three patients underwent concurrent CPM and three did not. Fiberoptic, radiographic. and manometric assessments were performed postoperatively. Although mean resting pressures at the upper esophageal sphincter were reduced significantly by myotomy (12 mm Hg) compared with nonmyotomized patients (57 mm Hg), p < 0.01, no rehabilitative advantage was observed in the former group. In fact, of the myotomized patients, two required feeding gastrostomy tubes with resumption of an oral diet in one year and in two months, respectively, while the nonmyotomized patients were all capable of resuming a full oral diet within four weeks. It appears that CPM provides no rehabilitative advantage in patients undergoing SL.