[Results of laparoscopic bilateral varicocelectomy]

Left varicocele (LV) is a common clinical condition that is present in approximately 15% of the general male population. Bilateral varicocele (BV) is an association of clinical LV and subclinical or ultrasound diagnosed right varicocele. Recent diagnostic technology suggests that BV is much more common than previously suspected varying from 15 to 57%. The laparoscopic technique offers the possibility of planning bilateral varix ligation but only a few reports are currently available. The aim of this study was to evaluate the outcome of contemporary bilateral correction of BV on spermatogenesis. From 1992 January to 1998 December a total of 207 patients with clinical left varicocele and a pathological sperm count were studied. Scrotal sonography was performed and in 96 patients (group A) subclinical right varicocele was diagnosed while 111 patients (group B) only had LV. 84 patients were married and had tried unsuccesfully for a pregnancy for at least one year before evaluation. All patients underwent laparoscopic varicocelectomy, performed under general anesthesia with a three trocar technique with application of clips to the spermatic vein and resection. Patients with right reflux received bilateral varix ligation. Operating time averaged 28 minutes for unilateral cases and 42 minutes for bilateral legatures. No significant differences were found in age distribution or preoperative seminal paramenters between the two groups. Postoperative hospital stay was 1.2 and 1.3 days respectively. 168 patients underwent sperm count four to six months after surgery. Both groups showed improvements in number (group A 41 millions, group b 27 millions), 2nd hour motility (group A 32%, group B 19%) and morphology (group A 52%, group B 51%). 95 patients achieved normalization of seminal parameters, 40 (63%) in group A and 37 (30%) in group B, and there was a statistically significant difference between the two groups. The pregnancy rate was calculated on married population after one year; it was 41% in total. The role of the subclinical right varicocele associated to clinical left varicocele is uncertain and there are few papers concerning this argument. In this serie normalization of seminal parameters and the pregnancy rate were significantly higher in patients with bilateral correction of reflux. In conclusion our data confirm that subclinical right reflux also has a detrimental effect on spermatogenesis and we suggest that it must be corrected contemporary when associated with clinical left varicocele.