Vesicular bodies in fish maculae are artifacts not contributing to otolith growth

The presence, morphology and possible origin of vesicle-like bodies (VBs) within the inner ear macular otolithic membrane of developmental stages of cichlid fish Oreochromis mossambicus and neonate (i.e. functionally fully developed except the reproductive organs) swordtail fish Xiphophorus helleri were analyzed by means of transmission and scanning electron microscopy (TEM and SEM, respectively) employing various fixation procedures. Some authors believe that these VBs are involved in the formation of the organic phase of inner ear otoliths (or statoliths in birds and mammals). Decreasing the osmolarity of the fixation medium from a value rather close to that of native fresh water fish tissue (i.e. 250 mOsm and 290--300 mOsm, respectively) to a value of fixatives mostly employed in TEM studies (ca. 190 mOsm), the amount of VBs increased and the components of sensory inner ear tissue increasingly dilated. Whilst a conventional prefixation with aldehydes followed by osmium tetroxide postfixation yielded numerous VBs, only few of them were observed when the tissue was fixed with aldehydes and osmium tetroxide simultaneously. Therefore, the results demonstrate that inner ear sensory epithelia are extremely sensitive to altering fixation media. On this background it must be concluded that VBs are fixative (i.e. glutaraldehyde) induced artificial structures, so-called membrane blisters. Thus, the protein matrix of otoliths (and possibly that of statoliths in higher vertebrates) is rather provided by secretion processes than by the release of vesicles.