Hydrogen peroxide formation during iron deposition in horse spleen ferritin using O2 as an oxidant

The reaction of Fe2+ with O2 in the presence of horse spleen ferritin (HoSF) results in deposition of FeOH3 into the hollow interior of HoSF. This reaction was examined at low Fe2+/HoSF ratios (5-100) under saturating air at pH 6.5-8.0 to determine if H2O2 is a product of the iron deposition reaction. Three methods specific for H2O2 detection were used to assess H2O2 formation: (1) a fluorometric method with emission at 590 nm, (2) an optical absorbance method based on the reaction H2O2 + 3I- + 2H+ = I3- + 2H2O monitored at 340 nm for I3- formation, and (3) a differential pulsed electrochemical method that measures O2 and H2O2 concentrations simultaneously. Detection limits of 0.25, 2.5, and 5.0 microM H2O2 were determined for the three methods, respectively. Under constant air-saturation conditions (20% O2) and for a 5-100 Fe2+/HoSF ratio, Fe2+ was oxidized and the resulting Fe3+ was deposited within HoSF but no H2O2 was detected as predicted by the reaction 2Fe2+ + O2 + 6H2O = 2Fe(OH)3 + H2O2 + 4H+. Two other sets of conditions were also examined: one with excess but nonsaturating O2 and another with limiting O2. No H2O2 was detected in either case. The absence of H2O2 formation under these same conditions was confirmed by microcoulometric measurements. Taken together, the results show that under low iron loading conditions (5-100 Fe2+/HoSF ratio), H2O2 is not produced during iron deposition into HoSF using O2 as an oxidant. This conclusion is inconsistent with previous, carefully conducted stoichiometric and kinetic measurements [Xu, B., and Chasteen, N. D. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 19965], predicting that H2O2 is a quantitative product of the iron deposition reaction with O2 as an oxidant, even though it was not directly detected. Possible explanations for these conflicting results are considered.