Acoustic and linguistic factors in the perception of bandpass-filtered speech

Speech can remain intelligible for listeners with normal hearing when processed by narrow bandpass filters that transmit only a small fraction of the audible spectrum. Two experiments investigated the basis for the high intelligibility of narrowband speech. Experiment 1 confirmed reports that everyday English sentences can be recognized accurately (82%-98% words correct) when filtered at center frequencies of 1500, 2100, and 3000 Hz. However, narrowband low predictability (LP) sentences were less accurately recognized than high predictability (HP) sentences (20% lower scores), and excised narrowband words were even less intelligible than LP sentences (a further 23% drop). While experiment 1 revealed similar levels of performance for narrowband and broadband sentences at conversational speech levels, experiment 2 showed that speech reception thresholds were substantially (>30 dB) poorer for narrowband sentences. One explanation for this increased disparity between narrowband and broadband speech at threshold (compared to conversational speech levels) is that spectral components in the sloping transition bands of the filters provide important cues for the recognition of narrowband speech, but these components become inaudible as the signal level is reduced. Experiment 2 also showed that performance was degraded by the introduction of a speech masker (a single competing talker). The elevation in threshold was similar for narrowband and broadband speech (11 dB, on average), but because the narrowband sentences required considerably higher sound levels to reach their thresholds in quiet compared to broadband sentences, their target-to-masker ratios were very different (+23 dB for narrowband sentences and -12 dB for broadband sentences). As in experiment 1, performance was better for HP than LP sentences. The LP-HP difference was larger for narrowband than broadband sentences, suggesting that context provides greater benefits when speech is distorted by narrow bandpass filtering.