Unique hues: an old problem for a new generation

The practical success of the classical theories of colour vision, such as that of Young-Helmholtz when applied to the measurement and reproduction of colour stimuli, and that of Hering's in art and architecture, has overshadowed the fact that neither theory achieved its main goal, namely to explain colour qualities. Neither the three types of cone, nor the first opponent stages of neural processing in the retina and the lateral geniculate nucleus can serve as direct correlates to the perception of elementary, or unique colours, such as red, green, yellow and blue. While our subjective experiences of these qualities do not submit to measurement, physiological conditions that are required to perceive colours of a constant hue can be identified. For instance, a constant ratio of responses of different types of opponent cells in the retina and the lateral geniculate nucleus of primates may serve as a neurophysiological correlate of a constant hue. This is, however, not the correlate for seeing a particular hue quality, say unique red. This latter correlate, if it exists as a separable entity, must be associated with yet unidentified, higher-level neural activities. The fundamental problems encountered in relating colour qualities to neural activities are discussed and references are made to the current debate about phenomenal consciousness.