Pulmonary gas exchange responses to histamine and methacholine challenges in mild asthma

Histamine (HIST) produces greater changes in bronchial and pulmonary vasculature, and so may produce more gas exchange abnormalities, than methacholine (MTH) after inhalational challenge. The goals of this study were to compare the effects of HIST and MTH challenge on pulmonary gas exchange in patients with mild asthma at an equivalent degree of bronchoconstriction. Eleven patients were studied (mean+/-SEM age, 22+/-1 yr; forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1), 91+/-5% pred) using a randomized, double-blind cross-over design. Respiratory system resistance (Rrs), arterial blood gases, and ventilation-perfusion distributions were measured before and after HIST/MTH challenges when cumulative doses caused a 30% fall in FEV1. Compared with baseline, HIST and MTH provoked similar moderate to severe increases in Rrs (p<0.005 each), and mild to moderate decreases in arterial oxygen tension (Pa,O2) due to ventilation-perfusion abnormalities (dispersion of pulmonary blood flow -log SDQ-, 0.40+/-0.03-0.71+/-0.08 and 0.47+/-0.04-0.89+/-0.06; normal values <0.60-0.65), respectively, similar to those shown in mild to moderate acute asthma, without differences between them. For the same degree of airflow obstruction, both histamine and methacholine bronchoprovocations induce, in patients with mild asthma, very similar disturbances in ventilation-perfusion distribution and respiratory system resistance, suggesting similar mechanisms of airway narrowing.