Comparative pathogenesis of Helicoverpa zea S nucleopolyhedrovirus in noctuid larvae

We used a recombinant of Helicoverpa zea S nucleopolyhedrovirus containing the hsp70/lacZ reporter cassette (HzSNPV-hsp70/lacZ) to quantify mortality relationships and to elucidate early pathogenesis in two permissive hosts, Heliothis virescens and Helicoverpa zea, and one semi-permissive host, Trichoplusia ni. Fourth instar T. ni were highly resistant to fatal infection both by oral injection of occlusions and by intrahaemocoelic injection of budded virus, indicating the presence of both midgut and systemic mechanisms of resistance. In bioassays, newly moulted (4(0)) H. zea were significantly more susceptible than 4(0) H. virescens to fatal infection, but mortality levels were the same for larval cohorts inoculated 16 h after the moult (4(16)). Developmental resistance was stronger in H. zea and in both hosts, partially reversed by administration of the optical brightener M2R. In both species, developmental resistance was correlated with a reduced ability of HzSNPV to establish and/or maintain primary midgut infections. In time-course experiments using a dosage of 15 occlusions ( approximately LD(90)), lacZ expression marking the onset of primary and secondary infection was first observed in midgut columnar and tracheal cells at 4 and 12 h, respectively. Inoculation of 4(0) larvae resulted in approximately twofold more foci in H. zea larvae than in H. virescens, but H. zea larvae sloughed infected midgut cells at a faster rate. For both heliothines, interaction of occlusion-derived virus with primary cellular targets within the midgut epithelium was critical to the outcome of infection and a key process underlying acquisition of developmental resistance.