Frequency of twinning in two Costa Rican ethnic groups: an update

Variation in the frequency of twinning among human populations has been presumed to reflect genetic differences. It has been commonly reported that populations of African ancestry have the highest, those of Asian ancestry the lowest, and those of European and Middle-Eastern ancestry intermediate frequencies of twinning. Populations from the Americas have been reported to have intermediate twinning frequencies, presumably reflecting their admixture. In this context, Madrigal (1994. Am J Hum Biol 6:215-218) reported virtually identical (and high) twinning frequencies in two Costa Rican ethnic groups, one of African, the other of Euro-Amerindian ancestry. These frequencies were interpreted in light of frequent inter-ethnic unions, and it was predicted that the two groups would not differ substantially in gene frequencies of several blood enzyme systems. This paper reports the gene frequencies of both groups for such systems. The samples differ significantly for systems that have clearly different frequencies in African and European populations. Given that the groups are actually different in gene frequencies and not homogenous as predicted earlier, the conclusion that twinning frequencies are similar as a result of a similar genetic make up can be questioned. The results challenge the assumption that if populations have similar twinning frequencies it is because they are genetically similar and argue for a stronger environmental component for twinning frequencies.