Thioester enolate stabilization in the acyl-CoA dehydrogenases: the effect of 5-deaza-flavin substitution

The redox-inactive thioester analog 3-thia-octanoyl-CoA blocks transfer of a hydride equivalent to the flavin prosthetic group of the medium-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase with the accumulation of a stable enolate intermediate not encountered with normal substrates. Substitution of the normal flavin with 5-deaza-FAD would thus be expected to lead to enolate formation with both normal and 3-thia-substrate analogs, because reduction of the 5-deaza-enzyme is thermodynamically highly unfavorable. However, spectrophotometric titrations show that neither ligand forms significant enolate species with the 5-deaza-FAD enzyme. Similarly, the substituted dehydrogenase catalyzes undetectable alpha-proton exchange with octanoyl-CoA and ca. 1% of the corresponding rate with 3-thia-octanoyl-CoA when compared to the native enzyme. This inability to stabilize enolate species is not simply due to impaired binding of CoA-thioester analogs, because binding of a range of ligands is weakened by only 2- to 10-fold with the 5-deaza-enzyme. 4-Thia-trans-2-enoyl-CoA product is polarized normally on binding to the substituted protein, showing that this critical aspect of catalysis is apparently normal. These data, together with studies with CoA-persulfide and acetoacetyl- and p-nitrophenylacetyl-CoA, suggest that 5-deaza-FAD substitution exerts subtle, unanticipated, effects on the reductive half-reaction of the medium-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase. The involvement of charge-transfer interactions in the acidification of weakly acidic acyl-CoA thioesters is discussed.