Aortic valve reoperation after homograft or autograft replacement

With increasing use of homograft and autograft aortic valves for aortic valve replacement (AVR), more patients will be presenting for aortic valve reoperation due to structural degeneration of the homograft or autograft valve. Management options include homograft re-replacement, which may require extensive surgery, versus AVR with a mechanical valve or a stented xenograft. Here, results are reported in 18 consecutive patients who underwent aortic valve re-replacement (AVreR) after previous homograft or autograft insertion.

Between May 1976 and March 2001, 18 patients underwent AVR after previous homograft (n = 16) or autograft (n = 2) insertion. The homograft or autograft had been implanted as a full root in eight patients (44%), as a mini-root in one (6%), and in the subcoronary position in nine (50%). Indication for the reoperation was structural valve degeneration (n = 14; 72%) in one occasion combined with aneurysm of the homograft, or endocarditis (n = 4; 22%), and seven (39%) presented as a non-elective procedure. The median interval between the two operations was 5.4 years (range: 0.3-10.8 years).

Fourteen patients (78%) received either a mechanical valve (n = 12; 67%) or a stented xenograft valve (n = 2; 11%). Four others (22%) required root re-replacement with either another homograft (n = 3) or a mechanical valved conduit (n = 1) for endocarditis (n = 2) or an associated aneurysm (n = 2). Overall hospital mortality was 11% (n = 2) due to stroke (n = 1) or respiratory failure (n = 1). Two patients died 3.1 and 7.0 years after the procedure.

Aortic valve reoperation after previous homograft or autograft implantation is a rare operation and presents a high-risk group. A simplified approach was preferred by utilizing mechanical or stented xenograft valves at reoperation, while homograft re-replacement was reserved for endocarditis or an associated aneurysm.