Ontogenetic differences in the effects of unpaired stimulus preexposure on eyeblink conditioning in the rat

Learned irrelevance (LIr) is a Pavlovian conditioning phenomenon in which random or unpaired preexposure to a conditional stimulus (CS) and to an unconditional stimulus (US) retards subsequent paired conditioning involving these stimuli. A previous developmental study of eyeblink conditioning in the rat suggested that LIr is not present on postnatal Day 20. Stanton, Fox, and Carter (1998) showed that unpaired preexposure to a CS and a US on postnatal Day 17 failed to retard (and, in fact, facilitated) subsequent paired conditioning involving these stimuli on postnatal Day 20. The present experiments were designed to further characterize the ontogeny of this phenomenon. In Experiment 1, LIr was observed when rat pups were tested for eyeblink conditioning as described in Stanton et al. (1998), except that preexposure occurred on postnatal Day 27, and acquisition testing occurred on postnatal Day 30. In Experiment 2, preexposure and acquisition both occurred on postnatal Day 30, and four types of preexposure were compared: chamber only, CS alone, US alone, or unpaired presentation of CS and US. Unpaired preexposure impaired acquisition relative to that of the remaining three groups, which did not differ. Experiment 3, showed that under the conditions of Experiment 2, LIr failed to appear on postnatal Day 20, but was observed on postnatal Days 25 and 30. These findings suggest that learning that events are unrelated emerges between postnatal Days 20 and 25 in the rat. Possible behavioral and neural mechanisms underlying this effect are discussed.