Cholangiocytic apoptosis in chronic ductopenic rejection

The significance of cholangiocytic apoptosis as a mechanism of ductopenia in liver rejection remains controversial. In a previous study, the presence but not the extent of ductal apoptosis was assessed by electron microscopy. Other previously published studies using an in situ hybridization method (in situ end labeling) produced conflicting results (no apoptosis v massive apoptosis). We studied 47 liver needle biopsies from 8 patients with chronic ductopenic rejection confirmed by pathologic examination of the failed grafts. These biopsies were performed because of graft dysfunction, during a period of several months before retransplantation, and they showed cholangiocytic injury with progressive ductal paucity. Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated deoxyuridine triphosphate-biotin nick-end labeling (TUNEL) was used to detect apoptosis (tissue digestion with proteinase K 20 microg/mL for 20 minutes). The interlobular bile ducts did not show labeling, even in lymphocytic cholangitis with obvious epithelial injury. However, there was minimal staining of ductular nuclei. Lymphocytic nuclei were also labeled. Apoptosis was not detectable in the vanishing interlobular bile ducts, even when more representative samples were studied and a more sensitive method was used. Unless apoptosis of cholangiocytes is an exceptionally rapid process escaping detection by conventional methods, ductopenia results mainly from ordinary, nonprogrammed cholangiocytic death. Apoptosis could still be involved in the pathogenesis of ductopenia by depleting cholangiocytic precursors, generally presumed to reside in ductules. This is a possible mechanism suggested by the following: (1) the established role of apoptosis in the homeostatic control of immature/progenitor cells, (2) the paucity of ductular proliferation in chronic rejection, (3) the previously reported decrease of ductular bcl-2 expression in rejection, and (4) the sporadic ductular TUNEL labeling seen in this study.