Related Experiment Video
Updated: Aug 7, 2026

Detecting Estrogenic Ligands in Personal Care Products using a Yeast Estrogen Screen Optimized for the Undergraduate Teaching Laboratory
Published on: January 1, 2018
Molecular classification of estrogens
V C Jordan1, J M Schafer, A S Levenson
1Robert H. Lurie Comprehensive Cancer Center, Northwestern University Medical School, Chicago, Illinois 60611, USA. vcjordan@northwestern.edu
Abstract:
Estrogens are involved in a multiplicity of programmed events in target tissues e.g.: uterus, breast, and pituitary gland, and hormone-responsive tumors occur at these target sites. We have addressed the possibility that all of the estrogens do not produce the same conformation of estrogen receptor alpha (ER). A novel assay in vitro was used to activate the transforming growth factor alpha (TGF-alpha) gene in situ in MDA-MB-231 cells stably transfected with cDNA for D351 ER or D351G ER. Three estrogen types were used: estradiol, diethylstilbestrol, and a triphenylethylene (TPE) derivative of tamoxifen without the antiestrogenic side chain. Computer molecular modeling was used to interpret data. A flat estrogen such as estradiol or diethylstilbestrol can induce TGF-alpha through a correctly positioned activating function 2 (AF2) and bind SRC-1. The TPE did not activate AF2 but activated the TGF-alpha gene through AF2b. This was demonstrated because D351 but not D351G ER activated the TGF-alpha gene with the TPE. We propose two classes of estrogens with different ER complexes that may incorporate different coactivators to function. Phytoestrogens and environmental xenoestrogens will fall into different classes based on structure and may exhibit selective actions and carcinogenic potential based on different ER conformations.
Insights
Different estrogens induce distinct estrogen receptor alpha (ER) conformations, influencing gene activation. This suggests classifying estrogens based on their ER interaction may predict selective actions and carcinogenic potential.
Area of Science:
- Endocrinology
- Molecular Biology
- Cancer Research
Background:
- Estrogens play crucial roles in target tissues like the uterus, breast, and pituitary gland, where hormone-responsive tumors frequently arise.
- The precise conformational changes induced in estrogen receptor alpha (ER) by various estrogens remain incompletely understood.
- Understanding ER conformation is vital for deciphering selective estrogen actions and carcinogenic potential.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate whether different estrogens induce distinct conformations of estrogen receptor alpha (ER).
- To explore the impact of these distinct ER conformations on the activation of the transforming growth factor alpha (TGF-alpha) gene.
- To propose a classification of estrogens based on their ER interaction and potential functional outcomes.
Main Methods:
- Utilized a novel in vitro assay to assess TGF-alpha gene activation in MDA-MB-231 cells expressing specific ER variants (D351 ER and D351G ER).
- Tested the effects of three distinct estrogen types: estradiol, diethylstilbestrol, and a triphenylethylene (TPE) derivative.
- Employed computer molecular modeling to interpret experimental data and elucidate ER-ligand interactions.
Main Results:
- Flat estrogens (estradiol, diethylstilbestrol) activated TGF-alpha via the canonical activating function 2 (AF2) domain, facilitating SRC-1 binding.
- The TPE derivative, however, activated TGF-alpha through an alternative pathway (AF2b), as evidenced by differential activation of D351 ER but not D351G ER.
- This differential activation highlights distinct ER conformational responses to different estrogen structures.
Conclusions:
- Propose the existence of two distinct classes of estrogens based on their ability to form different ER complexes.
- These distinct ER complexes may recruit different coactivators, leading to varied downstream effects.
- Estrogen structure dictates ER conformation, influencing selective actions and potentially carcinogenic outcomes of phytoestrogens and xenoestrogens.
Related Concept Videos
Types of Hormones
Structure and Nomenclature of Ethers
Ethers are organic compounds with an ether functional group which is characterized by an oxygen atom connected to two — identical or different — alkyl, aryl, or vinyl groups. The C–O–C linkage in dimethyl ether — the simplest ether — has an approximately tetrahedral bond angle of 110.3 degrees. The oxygen atom is sp3- hybridized, with the C–O distance being about 140 pm.
Classification of Ethers
Based on their attached substituent groups, ethers can be classified into two...
Isomerism
Polymer Classification: Stereospecificity
Transducer Mechanism: Nuclear Receptors
About 48 different soluble family members of nuclear receptors are identified that can be divided into two main classes:
Types of Hormones
Steroids and eicosanoids fall under the category of lipid-soluble hormones. Steroids are derived from cholesterol and feature four interconnected carbon rings with variable side chains. Notable examples include estradiol from ovaries and testosterone from testes, exemplifying the critical roles of these lipid-soluble hormones in reproductive physiology. Eicosanoids, derived...

