Revisiting Markovnikov addition to alkenes via molecular electrostatic potential

Molecular electrostatic potentials (MESP) surrounding the pi-region of several substituted ethylenes (CH(2)CHR) have been characterized by locating the most negative-valued point (V(min)) in that region. The substituents have been classified as electron donating and withdrawing on the basis of the increase or decrease in the negative character of V(min) in these systems as compared to ethylene. The values of V(min) show a good linear correlation with the Hammett sigma(p) constants, suggesting that the substituent electronic effects in substituted ethylenes and substituted benzenes are basically similar. With electron-donating substituents, the position of MESP minimum is closer to the unsubstituted carbon facilitating the pi-complex formation of it with HCl at this site. Such a regiospecific pi-complex formation is found to favor the formation of Markovnikov-type transition state for the addition of HCl to CH(2)CHR. For the electron-withdrawing substituents, the V(min) location is almost equidistant and farther from the ethylenic carbon atoms. This and the less negative V(min) values account for the less regiospecific CH(2)CHR...HCl pi-complexes as well as the transition states for the HCl addition to CH(2)CHR when R is an electron-withdrawing group. The interaction energy (E(int)) between CH(2)CHR and HCl for the formation of the CH(2)CHR...HCl pi-complex shows a good linear correlation with the corresponding V(min) value.