Search research articles

ABOUT JoVE

Overview Leadership Blog JoVE Help Center

AUTHORS

Publishing Process Editorial Board Scope & Policies Peer Review FAQ Submit

LIBRARIANS

Testimonials Subscriptions Access Resources Library Advisory Board FAQ

RESEARCH

JoVE Journal Methods Collections JoVE Encyclopedia of Experiments Archive

EDUCATION

JoVE Core JoVE Business JoVE Science Education JoVE Lab Manual Faculty Resource Center Faculty Site

Terms & Conditions of Use

Search research articles

Related Experiment Videos

Paternalism and the argument from illiteracy.

|July 1, 1995

Summary

Paternalism towards illiterate individuals is often justified by claims of their inability to make informed decisions. This essay critically examines this argument, questioning the assumption that illiteracy negates autonomy and informed consent.

Related Concept Videos

You might also read

Related Articles

Articles linked to this work by shared authors, journal, and citation graph.

Sort by

Same author

Rethinking ethical reflexivity and oversight in health research through an ecosystem approach: A workshop report.

Research ethics·2026

Same author

Vulnerability: On a Welcome Paradigm Shift in the 2024 Declaration of Helsinki.

Bioethics·2025

Same author

What vaccine inequity has taught us: a way forward through the lens of ideal and non-ideal theory.

Global bioethics = Problemi di bioetica·2025

Same author

Fogarty-Funded Research Ethics Education in Latin America and the Caribbean: Progress Despite Ongoing Challenges.

Journal of empirical research on human research ethics : JERHRE·2025

Same author

Informed consent and living wills: comparative analysis of the legislation in Latin America.

Revista de bioetica y derecho & perspectivas bioeticas·2024

Same author

[Digital health in Latin America: current legislation and ethical aspectsSaúde digital na América Latina: legislação atual e aspectos éticos].

Revista panamericana de salud publica = Pan American journal of public health·2024

Area of Science:

Bioethics
Medical Ethics
Philosophy of Medicine

Background:

The argument for paternalism towards illiterate individuals often assumes they lack decision-making capacity.
This justification is prevalent in some Latin American countries, particularly Argentina.
The ethical implications of this paternalistic stance require careful consideration.

Purpose of the Study:

To critically analyze the argument that justifies paternalism towards illiterate people.
To evaluate the ethical acceptability of denying autonomy to illiterate individuals.
To explore the implications of assuming illiteracy equates to an inability to make informed decisions.

Main Methods:

Philosophical analysis of ethical arguments.
Examination of the concept of autonomy in relation to literacy.
A priori reasoning critique.

Main Results:

The argument for paternalism based on illiteracy relies on questionable assumptions about communication and understanding.
Denying autonomy to illiterate individuals may stem from an uncritical acceptance of flawed reasoning.
The ethical justification for paternalism in this context is debatable and requires deeper scrutiny.

Conclusions:

The assumption that illiterate individuals cannot be autonomous is ethically problematic.
Paternalistic practices towards illiterate patients warrant re-evaluation based on a more nuanced understanding of their capacity for informed consent.
Further discussion is needed to ensure ethical treatment and respect for autonomy regardless of literacy levels.

Keywords:

Professional Patient Relationship

Related Experiment Videos