Origins of Enantioselectivity with Nitrogen-Sulfur Chelate Ligands in Palladium-Catalyzed Allylic Substitution

The reaction of 1,3-diphenyl-2-propenyl acetate (9) with dimethylmalonate to give the substitution product 10 is effectively catalyzed by Pd complexes containing chiral imine-sulfide chelate ligands derived from amino acids. The ligand of choice, (S)-N-2'-chlorobenzylidene-2-amino-3-methyl-1-thiophenylbutane (6e), prepared in only two steps from (S)-valinol, gave an ee of 94%. Because the explanation of selectivity with the majority of other nitrogen-sulfur chelate ligands in this reaction assumes the selectivity to be controlled by an electronic bias, which contradicts our results, we characterized the Pd-allyl intermediate 14 by X-ray diffraction and solution NMR. The possible mechanism of chirality transfer is discussed. The site of nucleophilic attack on the allyl ligand is not trans to the perceived better pi-acceptor ligand (sulfur), which would be analogous to chiral nitrogen-phosphorus systems. This reaction occurs trans to the imine donor, and the enantioselectivity is ultimately controlled by the subtle steric environment of the chiral imine-sulfur chelate ligand, which predisposes the allyl unit of the reaction intermediate to a preferred reaction trajectory. In light of results that emphasize the power of electronic desymmetrization for chiral recognition, these results suggest that electronically dissimilar ligands may not give rise to chiral recognition through electronic dissimilarity.