Separation of binaphthol enantiomers through achiral chromatography

Chromatography is a key technique for the analytical, preparative, and production scale separation of enantiomers, particularly in the pharmaceutical and fine chemicals industries. Although it is common belief that this separation can be accomplished only using a chiral stationary phase, it has been recently shown that under certain circumstances a non-racemic mixture of specific chiral compounds can be separated in two fractions which differ in enantiomeric excess (e.e.) also on an achiral stationary phase. In this work we show that in the case of the enantiomers of binaphthol in chloroform achiral chromatography on LiChrospher 100 NH2 furnishes two fractions constituted of the pure enantiomer present in excess and of the racemic mixture, respectively. This is demonstrated by on-line monitoring the concentration of both enantiomers at the outlet of a chromatographic column fed with a non-racemic pulse of the two enantiomers by using a UV detector and a polarimeter in series. Furthermore, we provide experimental evidence of the presence of homo- and hetero-dimers in solution through NMR experiments and develop a consistent physico-chemical model of the solution itself and of the competitive achiral adsorption equilibria. When combined with a standard rate model of the chromatographic column this not only confirms the possibility of achieving 100% e.e. through achiral chromatography, but also allows for a qualitative and quantitative description of all the experimentally observed phenomena. Among these, the effect of the enantiomeric excess and of the overall concentration of the injected pulse on the chromatographic behaviour are worth mentioning.