Homocysteine and atherothrombosis

Atherosclerosis with or without thrombosis superimposed is the most frequent cause of ischemic heart disease (IHD), peripheral arterial disease, and a main cause of stroke. Conflicting results have been reported in genetic, observational, and experimental studies on the relationship between homocysteine and these atherothrombotic diseases. Although cardiovascular complications are common in homocystinuric patients (severe hyperhomocysteinemia), IHD, the most frequent manifestation of atherothrombosis in the general population, appears to be rare. On the basis of findings in individuals with hyperhomocysteinemia of genetic origin, there is in fact no clear evidence for a causal role of homocysteine in the pathogenesis of atherothrombotic disease, and the positive association between plasma homocysteine and IHD observed in many, but not all epidemiologic studies does not prove causality. To infer causality from observational studies, there should be a temporal, consistent, strong, independent, graded (dose-response effect), and duration-dependent relationship between exposure and outcomes, and a biologically plausible mechanism should exist. The relationship between plasma homocysteine levels and IHD does not fulfill these criteria beyond reasonable doubt. In the general population, plasma homocysteine levels are to a great extent determined by dietary habits, and plasma homocysteine could be a marker, or a consequence, of atherothrombosis and/or risk-associated behavior (e.g., a diet low in fruits and vegetables) rather than a cause of atherothrombosis. Experimentally, hyperhomocysteinemia is not in itself atherogenic in normal animals with relatively low plasma cholesterol levels. The homocysteine theory of atherosclerosis should be tested more thoroughly in hypercholesterolemic animals that develop atherosclerosis spontaneously to determine whether elevated plasma homocysteine levels are harmful under atherogenic conditions. A causal role of homocysteine in atherothrombotic disease remains to be established.