Control of stability through overlap matching: closo-carborynes and closo-silaborynes

The matching of ring and cap orbitals for overlap is used to arrive at the best carborynes among the many possibilities. Accordingly, 1,2-carboranes, 1,2-silaboranes (C2BnHn+2, and Si2BnHn+2, n = 4, 5, 8, and 10), and their dehydrogeno derivatives were studied with use of the Density Functional Theory (B3LYP/6-311+G*). The dehydrogenation of 2,3-C2B5H7 (6a) to 2,3-C2B5H5 (13a) is estimated to be even less endothermic than those of benzene and 1,2- C2B10H12 (1a) to benzyne and 1,2-C2B10H10 (8a) by more than 21 kcal/mol. This is due to the extra stabilization gained through better overlap of the C2B3H3 ring with the 2 BH caps. The relatively larger size of the Si atom leads to overlap requirements in silaboranes that are different from those in carboranes. The lower Si-Si single bond energy and the preference of Si for lower coordination result in unusual structures in dehydrogenosilaboranes. One of the Si atoms moves away from the surface in Si2B10H10 (15), Si2B8H8 (16, 17, and 18), and 1,2-Si2B5H5 (19). One Si atom forms a bridge to a trigonal surface in 2,3-Si2B5H5 (20) and 1,2-Si2B4H4 (21). Estimates of three-dimensional aromaticity with NICS calculations show that the exohedral double bond does not influence three-dimensional aromaticity.