Related Experiment Videos
Personal observations on the cultural evolution in academic surgery
1The Oliver H. Payne Professor, Department of Surgery, Case Western Reserve University, USA. jms24@po.cwru.edu
American Journal of Surgery
|April 27, 2002
Summary
Academic surgery leadership has shifted from clan and adhocracy cultures to hierarchical and market-driven models. Chairmen are older but serve shorter terms, necessitating adaptation to evolving departmental priorities.
Area of Science:
- Organizational behavior in academic medical centers
- Leadership dynamics in academic surgery
- Surgical department management
Background:
- Academic medical centers face environmental changes impacting leadership recruitment and demographics.
- Business models of organizational culture, including clan, adhocracy, hierarchy, and market-driven types, are applied to academic surgery.
Observation:
- Surveys of academic surgical chairmen in 1981 and 2001 assessed changes in leadership demographics and organizational culture.
- The study aimed to identify shifts in the characteristics of individuals attracted to leadership roles and demographic changes over two decades.
Findings:
- Academic surgical departments evolved from clan/adhocracy to hierarchical/market-driven cultures over two decades.
- The mean age of appointed chairmen increased from 44 (1981) to 49 (2001).
- Average tenure ('years in grade') decreased from 9.4 (1981) to 7.1 (2001), indicating shorter leadership terms.
Implications:
- Academic surgery has undergone significant cultural evolution, altering chairman priorities.
- Successful departmental leadership requires adapting to these cultural shifts and understanding the evolving role of the chairman.