Related Experiment Videos
Punishment revisited--science, values, and the right question: comment on Gershoff (2002)
1Department of Psychology, University of California, Riverside 92521, USA. ross.parke@ucr.edu
Psychological Bulletin
|June 26, 2002
Summary
This commentary reviews punishment research, emphasizing its context within socialization and parental values. Future studies should adopt family-systems and culturally sensitive approaches for a comprehensive understanding of disciplinary tactics.
Area of Science:
- Developmental Psychology
- Family Studies
- Sociology of the Family
Background:
- Reviews historical phases of punishment research.
- Highlights punishment as a packaged variable within socialization.
- Underscores the need to consider parental values in punishment effectiveness.
Discussion:
- Advocates for viewing punishment not in isolation but as part of a package of socialization tactics.
- Stresses the importance of parental values in understanding the utilization and efficacy of disciplinary methods.
- Calls for a shift from simplistic views to a more nuanced understanding of punishment's role.
Key Insights:
- Punishment research requires a holistic approach, integrating it with other socialization methods.
- Parental values significantly influence the application and outcomes of disciplinary strategies.
- Existing research paradigms may be insufficient for capturing the complexity of punishment.
Outlook:
- Recommends a family-systems perspective to understand punishment within the family unit.
- Suggests a family-typology approach to differentiate responses to punishment across diverse family structures.
- Proposes a transactional model, innovative observation, self-report methods, and culturally sensitive paradigms for future research.