The effects of different hernia repair methods on postoperative pain medication and CRP levels

Although tension-free techniques of hernia repair using synthetic meshes have yielded encouraging results, the best method of inguinal hernia repair is still unclear. The aim of this study was to compare the responses of inflammatory mediators and postoperative pain relief following laparoscopic total extraperitoneal (TEP) hernioplasty, open tension-free mesh hernioplasty (Lichtenstein), posterior preperitoneal mesh hernioplasty (Nyhus procedure), and Bassini procedure. Patients with primary inguinal hernia were randomized in the operating room to undergo one of these repair techniques. Group I comprised 24 patients treated by Lichtenstein procedure; Group II comprised 21 patients treated by Nyhus procedure; Group III comprised 19 patients treated by Bassini procedure; and Group IV comprised 20 patients treated by laparoscopic TEP mesh hernioplasty. Postoperative pain levels following hernia repair were compared by measuring the use of patient-controlled analgesia (PCA) during the 24 hours after surgery. Serum samples withdrawn before surgery and 48 hours after surgery were assayed for C-reactive protein (CRP) content. Patient characteristics, operating time, and operative and early complications were noted. Serum CRP levels rose markedly following Nyhus (184.5 +/- 41.6 mg/L), Lichtenstein (138.4 +/- 72.5 mg/L), and Bassini repair (137.2 +/- 55.9 mg/L) compared with that of patients who underwent TEP mesh hernioplasty (55.5 +/- 41.2 mg/L). There were also significant differences in the postoperative need for analgesics via PCA among patients undergoing Nyhus (382.9 +/- 189.1 mg), Bassini (303.2 +/- 173.7 mg), and Lichtenstein (253.9 +/- 129.3) procedures compared with 196.6 +/- 148.8 mg for the TEP mesh hernioplasty group. Patients in the Lichtenstein group also had significantly less need of analgesics than those in the Nyhus and Bassini groups. In conclusion, TEP mesh hernioplasty is less traumatic and yields less postoperative pain than the Nyhus, Lichtenstein, and Bassini procedures.