Evaluation of C-H cdots, three dots, centered O hydrogen bonds in native and misfolded proteins

Non-traditional C-H cdots, three dots, centered Y hydrogen bonds, in which a carbon atom acts as the hydrogen donor and an electronegative atom Y (Y=N, O or S) acts as the acceptor, have been reported in proteins, but their importance in protein structures is not well established. Here, we present the results of three computational tests that examine the significance of C-H cdots, three dots, centered Y bonds involving the C(alpha) in proteins. First, we compared the number of C(alpha)-H cdots, three dots, centered Y bonds in native structures with two sets of compact, energy-minimized decoy structures. The decoy structures contain about as many C(alpha)-H cdots, three dots, centered Y bonds as the native structures, indicating that the constraints of chain connectivity and compactness can lead to incidental formation of C(alpha)-H cdots, three dots, centered Y bonds. Secondly, we examined whether short C(alpha)-H cdots, three dots, centered Y bonds have a tendency to be linear, as is expected for a cohesive hydrogen-bonding interaction. The native structures do show this trend, but so does one of the decoy sets, suggesting that this criterion is also not sufficient to indicate a stabilizing interaction. Finally, we examined the preference for C(alpha)-H cdots, three dots, centered Y bond donors to be near to strong hydrogen bond acceptors. In the native proteins, the alpha protons attract strong acceptors like oxygen atoms more than weak acceptors. In contrast, hydrogen bond donors in the decoy structures do not distinguish between strong and weak acceptors. Thus, any individual C(alpha)-H cdots, three dots, centered Y bond may be fortuitous and occur due to the polypeptide connectivity and compactness. Taken collectively, however, C(alpha)-H cdots, three dots, centered Y bonds provide a weakly cohesive force that stabilizes proteins.