Edwards, Benner and Wrubel on caring

Area of Science:

• Philosophy of Science
• Phenomenology
• Nursing Theory

Background:

• Critiques of Benner and Wrubel's concept of ontological care, particularly Edwards' paper.
• Analysis of Benner and Wrubel's misunderstanding of Heideggerian philosophy in their response.
• Examination of the distinction between ontological and intentional care within nursing theory.

Discussion:

• Explanation of the Heideggerian concept of the ontological difference.
• How a misinterpretation of Heidegger undermines Benner and Wrubel's arguments.
• Critique of the foundational claims regarding ontological care in nursing practice.

Key Insights:

• Benner and Wrubel's application of Heideggerian concepts is fundamentally flawed.
• The category of ontological care, as presented by Benner and Wrubel, lacks a sound philosophical basis.
• The authors' philosophical underpinnings are not as radical or novel as claimed.

Outlook:

• Re-evaluation of care theories in nursing through a more accurate philosophical lens.
• Implications for understanding the nature of care beyond intentionality.
• Potential for revised theoretical frameworks in nursing that correctly integrate philosophical concepts.