Detection of alloreactive T cells by flow cytometry: a new test compared with limiting dilution assay

Frequencies of alloreactive T cells determined by limiting dilution assays (LDA) may not adequately reflect the donor-reactive immune status in transplant recipients. To reevaluate LDA frequencies, we developed a flow cytometry test for direct determination of alloreactive T-cell frequencies and compared these frequencies with classical LDA estimates of frequencies.

For determination of frequencies by flow cytometry, peripheral blood lymphocytes (or lymphocytes taken from primary mixed lymphocyte culture) were stimulated with either Epstein-Barr virus-transformed lymphoblastoid cell lines or T cell-depleted spleen cells and stained for intracellular interferon (IFN)-gamma production and CD69. In lung transplant recipients, frequencies of IFN+ alloreactive T cells were compared with LDA frequencies, that is, cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors and helper T lymphocyte precursors.

With flow cytometry, alloreactive T cells were detected after overnight allostimulation as IFN-gamma CD69bright cells (range, 0.1-0.58% and 0.1-0.66% of total CD4 and CD8 cells, respectively). Frequencies increased 25-fold or more when lymphocytes were prestimulated in primary mixed lymphocyte culture before testing. After lung transplantation, mean donor-specific IFN+ CD8 T-cell frequencies did not decrease as mean donor-specific LDA cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor frequencies, whereas no difference was seen in pretransplantation samples or third-party-specific frequencies at both time points. Mean frequencies of IFN+ CD4 did not differ from helper T lymphocyte precursors at both time points, but frequencies did not correlate.

The flow cytometry test allows a direct measurement of alloreactive T-cell frequencies and demonstrates a discrepancy between donor-specific IFN+ CD8 T-cell frequencies and LDA CLTp after transplantation. This may be a result of the existence of "functional diverse" alloreactive T cells or of activation-induced cell death of donor-reactive T cells during long (LDA) culturing, which is avoided in the flow cytometry test.