Major colorectal cancer resection should not be denied to the elderly

Adjuvant therapy after surgery for colorectal cancer is often denied to the elderly for various reasons. This study was to determine morbidity and mortality risk after surgery in the elderly and whether this is affected by adjuvant therapy.

Data were collected prospectively and entered on a database for all patients undergoing resection of colorectal cancer between January 1994 and July 2000. A total of 304 patients were included, 65 aged 80 years and over.

There were 84 deaths, 21 (30%) in the over 80s, and 63 (26%) in the under 80s (P=0.51). The 'in-hospital' mortality was 10.1% in the over 80s and 3.8% in the under 80s (P=0.056). In the over 80s the colon was more affected than the rectum (P=0.002). The over 80s were less likely to be offered adjuvant therapy, 7.2% vs 42.1% (P<0.001). The 5 year survival (all-cause mortality) in the over 80s was 58.5% and 47.6% in the under 80s (P=0.25). Cox's regression analysis of all patients identified the following factors to be independently related to overall survival: age>80 years, post-operative leak, increasing Dukes stage and distant recurrence of disease.

This study has demonstrated that surgery should not be denied to elderly patients with colorectal cancer as despite a higher post-operative morbidity and mortality rate and with the absence of adjuvant therapy, favourable long-term outcome can be achieved by resectional surgery alone.