Related Experiment Video
Updated: Aug 13, 2026
Diagnosis of Neoplasia in Barrett’s Esophagus using Vital-dye Enhanced Fluorescence Imaging
Published on: May 11, 2014
High grade abnormalities following an 'inconclusive' smear
S Valmadre1, K Atkinson, R Houghton
1Colposcopy Service, Sydney Gynaecological Oncology Group, King George V and Royal Prince Alfred Hospitals, New South Wales, Australia.
Objective:
The National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) recommends a report of 'inconclusive possible high grade epithelial abnormality', but many laboratories only report 'inconclusive' with reference to any possible high grade disease elsewhere in the report. This study was performed to determine possible reasons for cytological difficulties resulting in this category of report and to determine the rate of significant disease within this category.
Design:
Retrospective record review. Clinical details were extracted without patient-identifying data.
Setting:
Gynaecological Oncology Department, King George V/Royal Prince Alfred Hospital.
Population:
Two hundred patients referred with the cytological abnormality.
Materials And Methods:
An adequate colposcopic diagram documenting size, distribution and grade of lesion was required. All patients had colposcopy with management according to colposcopic and histological results as appropriate to their disease.
Outcome Measures:
Colposcopic features, topography and size of any lesion, histological results, treatments performed and subsequent review of untreated patients.
Results:
Colposcopy found high-grade lesions in 43% and carcinoma in 1%. Histopathology found 49% and 4% respectively. Treatment was performed in 124 patients. Inflammation was found in 27%, a small lesion in 43% and endocervical disease in 21%.
Conclusions:
The high rate of endocervical disease, inflammation and small lesions may explain the cytological difficulties leading to an 'inconclusive' result. The authors believe that the term 'inconclusive' alone does not adequately convey the high level of risk faced by these patients.
