A model system for the design of armed replicating adenoviruses using p53 as a candidate transgene

Cancer gene therapy endeavors to overcome the low therapeutic index of currently available therapeutic modalities via the efficient and safe delivery of genetic material into tumor cells. However, despite promising preclinical results, replication-deficient viral vectors have demonstrated a limited efficacy in the clinical setting. To increase vector efficiency, replication-competent viruses have been proposed. Clinical trials have shown the safety of locally injected, conditionally replicative adenoviruses (Ads) but have underscored the need for improved potency. To further increase the therapeutic effect of replicating viral vectors, armed therapeutic viruses (ATVs) have recently been used for high-efficiency transgene expression. However, interference with cellular signaling and viral production by constitutive transgene expression may be counterproductive for ATV replication, thereby hindering the therapeutic outcome. Consequently, studies are equivocal with regard to the potential benefits of ATVs. To address this issue, we hypothesized that induction of replication of an Ad expressing p53 may be a useful strategy in the context of ATV because p53 does not interfere with Ad replication and may even increase its cytolytic effect. We show that in our in vitro ATV model system, E1 transcomplementation of a replication-deficient Ad encoding p53 resulted in dramatic augmentation of cell killing and circumvented resistance to apoptosis. Correlation was found between the degrees of cell killing and apoptosis induction, rather than with viral burst. Furthermore, both Ad5 E1B 55kDa and E4 orf6 genes were required to enhance the cell killing. In conclusion, our p53-ATV model system demonstrates the potential utility of therapeutic transgene expression by a replicating Ad after a rational selection of a candidate transgene.